Wilting Point is An Overlooked Drought Tolerance Trait in Rice
Bermenito Punzalan1, Ma. Rebecca Laza2, Yulieth Vargas3, Camila Rebolledo3,4, and Michael Dingkuhn4*
1Ayala Land Estates, Inc., Planning, Innovation & Design Group. Ayala Triangle, Makati City, Philippines (Formerly
at International Rice Research Institute); 2International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), Los Baños 4031, Philippines;
3 International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT), Agrobiodiversity Research Area, Cali, Colombia; 4CIRAD,
UMR AGAP Institut (Univ Montpellier – CIRAD – INRAE – Institut Agro), Montpellier 34398, France.
*Corresponding author, michael.dingkuhn@cirad.fr
Abstract
The soil moisture tension (SMT) at wilting point is by convention estimated at 15 bar (pF 4.2) and
is thought to vary little among species and crop varieties. However, as rice is particularly drought
sensitive, its wilting point may differ from this value and show genetic diversity. We phenotyped
the critical SMT at which transpiration ceases as a genotypic trait for the PRAY-indica diversity
panel (300 accessions). A dry-down approach in pots was used during tillering stage in
greenhouse and phytotron experiments. Soil evaporation was suppressed and weight loss
attributed to plant transpiration alone. Once weight was constant and plants terminally stressed,
gravimetric soil moisture content was measured and converted to SMT by pF curve. Both
experiments had three replicates as randomized blocks. Observed critical SMT varied significantly
(P<0.0001) between 3 and 5 bar among genotypes, translating into a 14% difference in water
extracted between these extrema in the paddy soil used. Dryland-adapted cultivars extracted more
water than flooding-adapted ones. Broad-sense heritability (H2) was between 0.61 and 0.72. A
genome-wide association study (GWAS) identified 6 quantitative trait loci (QTL), co-localizing with
4 functionally plausible candidate genes, including two root nitrate reductases. In conclusion, the
conventional wilting point does not apply to indica rice, which is much more sensitive. This has
consequences for the calculation of the fraction of transpirable soil water (FTSW) parameter used
in crop models. The observed genotypic differences and QTLs indicate that this new trait may
useful in for breeding for drought tolerance.
Keywords: Climate change, Fraction of Transpirable Soil Water (FTSW), Genome-Wide Association Studies(GWAS), Oryza sativa L., soil moisture tension, soil water extraction
Vol 48 - 3 December 2023